When Roy Walford was just a boy, he figured out
that science could fix his biggest complaint: Life is too
short
DISCOVER Vol. 21 No. 02 | February 2000
Walford believes a draconian diet will postpone
the day when he has to seriously contemplate his own
mortality. Even though a nerve disorder makes it
difficult for him to walk from one end of his Venice,
California, apartment to the other, he hopes to live
another half century. “If I don’t, it doesn’t prove
anything,” he says. “It’s like doing an experiment on
one mouse.” |
Venice, California, is as good a place as any to stay young
forever. The sun shines 11 months a year, the temperature
never strays too far from perfect, and the famous (or
infamous) boardwalk is home to more than its share of
eccentrics, surfers, bikini-clad roller skaters, and body
worshipers. Roy Walford, professor emeritus of pathology at
the University of California, Los Angeles, School of Medicine,
would have to be considered one of the eccentrics, although he
manages to stand out even among the denizens of Venice Beach.
Walford lives in a one-story, redbrick industrial
building, one block from the beach. The windows are boarded
over. The entrance is in back, off an alleyway, through a
wrought-iron gate. Inside, Walford waits behind his desk with
a shaved head and a dramatic Fu Manchu mustache of the kind
more commonly seen adorning the members of outlaw motorcycle
gangs than scientists.
For Walford to
seem out of character is hardly new. This is not a person who
has led the closeted life of an academic or buried himself in
a laboratory, despite the obsession with which he has pursued
his science. For the better part of 50 years he has dedicated
his life and his research to the belief that threescore years
and fifteen is woefully short for a human life span and that
we should all live decades longer. And he’s had some success.
His most important work has focused on the relationship
between eating and longevity. In a seminal series of
experiments beginning in the 1960s, Walford studied the effect
of depriving laboratory mice of calories and discovered that
the less they ate—within reason—the longer they lived. The
research convinced him that it might be worthwhile to apply
the same lessons to himself. So since the early 1980s, he has
followed what he describes as a near-starvation diet. Walford
believes that his diet of a mere 1,600 or so calories a
day—about a third to a half less than a man his size would
normally consume—will give him the best possible chance of
living to 120.
And this is where the problem comes in. Here Walford sits
at age 75, still doing research, working on half a dozen
projects simultaneously, and yet he finds it difficult to
walk. A chronic nerve disorder he picked up nearly 10 years
ago as a volunteer guinea pig in a surreal ecosystem
experiment makes living to 120 seem an even more ludicrous
goal than it was back when he was able to walk normally.
While Walford’s condition has impaired his balance and his
mobility, his will seems unaffected: “I have to try to walk
consciously instead of unconsciously. Conscious walking means
you balance on one foot and then the other and you fall
forward.” He says this quietly, with precise, controlled
gestures, as if saving energy for the next decade. As one
might expect of a man with this kind of willpower, he is thin.
But at 5 feet 8 inches and 134 pounds—some 15 pounds less than
he weighed as a college wrestler—he still has a muscular
physique, the product of every-other-day weight workouts at a
local gym. And his nerve condition has certainly not kept him
from his goal of understanding aging. He visits his ucla
laboratory a few times a week to work on a “crucial
experiment” he hopes will give him an immunological answer to
postponing the toll of time.
Walford’s new research is based on the fact that in mice
and humans, the immune system malfunctions during aging,
losing the ability to distinguish between healthy cells and
invasive pathogens such as bacteria and viruses. Eventually
the system begins to mount so-called autoimmune attacks
against the body itself. Walford has long theorized that this
is a root cause of the regrettable side effects of aging, and
he still hopes to find out if he’s right. To test the theory,
he is raising mice with defective immune systems in an
ultraclean environment. “In a normal environment, they’d just
die of infection,” he says. “But I want to see if they have
correspondingly less autoimmunity and how that influences
their survival in a world without pathogens.”
If the mice live longer, Walford will have provided
formidable support to his immunological theory of aging, which
might have dramatic benefits for future generations. After
all, as he has pointed out, if human aging were completely
preventable, and disease eradicated, the average life span
might be about 300 years. Everyone would eventually die from
accidents, but those who are lucky might live to be 600.
Even as a youngster, Walford considered life entirely too
full of opportunities to imagine their fitting into one life
span. He grew up in San Diego, the son of a career naval
officer. He was the top student in his high-school class, as
well as a first-rate gymnast, wrestler and jitterbug dancer.
At 17 he announced in an article for his school newspaper that
the human life span was unacceptably short. As an
undergraduate at the California Institute of Technology, he
thought about studying philosophy, physics, and mathematics,
but settled on premed. “We used to joke that together we would
conquer three great challenges: space, time, and death,” says
his Caltech roommate, Al Hibbs, now a retired nasa space
scientist. “I was supposed to conquer space, Roy was supposed
to conquer death; together we would build a time machine. They
were young men’s fantasies, but he got interested in them
seriously.”
After graduation, both Hibbs and Walford went to the
University of Chicago—Walford for his medical degree, Hibbs
for a master’s degree in mathematics. There, Walford became
involved in theater and wrote his own comedic adaptation of
Christopher Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus. He picked up spare cash
performing in a balancing act, in which he was held aloft by a
biologist-cum-weight lifter. Before earning his M.D. in 1948,
he began practicing what he later dubbed his theory of
signposts. The essence of the theory is that life will become
an unmemorable blur unless people engage occasionally in what
Walford describes as “rather crazy” activities, which act as
signposts marking the passage of the years. In this case, he
and Hibbs made plans to sail around the world. They lacked
only the boat and the money to buy it with. So they decided to
play roulette.
“We figured the only way of getting money without having to
work at it was either to rob a bank or win at the casinos,”
says Hibbs. The two analyzed roulette tables, with the
knowledge that the tables aren’t mathematically perfect. “Some
numbers come up more often than they should,” says Walford.
They raked in $6,000 in Reno and $30,000 in Las Vegas, an
achievement heralded by Life magazine in an article headlined
“Two Student Theoreticians Invent System for Beating Roulette
Wheel.” Then they bought a yacht and set off on their sailing
adventure.
The plan was to cover the day-to-day expenses
for the trip by writing for Science Illustrated magazine. But
the magazine folded and, after 18 months of sailing, the duo
found themselves stranded in the Caribbean. So Hibbs
eventually returned to Caltech for his Ph.D., and Walford
headed to Panama for his medical internship. Following two
years at a veterans affairs hospital in Los Angeles and
another two at an Air Force pathology laboratory in Illinois,
Walford joined the medical faculty of ucla in 1954 and began
delving into the aging process.
Working with mice in the laboratory, he
quickly realized the benefits of the mantra of caloric
restriction research: undernutrition without malnutrition. The
maximum life span of a typical lab mouse is 39 months,
corresponding to 110 years in humans. Walford and researchers
have demonstrated that mice that eat only 60 percent of their
preferred diet will live as long as 56 months—the equivalent
of 165 human years—provided they start their diets before
three months of age. Although these mice are smaller than
their normally fed peers, they seem to retain their
youthfulness and intellects well into their extended old age.
“We’ve found that a 36-month-old restricted mouse will run a
maze with the same facility as a six-month-old normally fed
mouse,” Walford says. “That’s a substantial preservation of
intellectual function.”
SIGNPOSTS OF A
LIFE
Walford (above) motorcycled across
the U.S. in 1947; Right: Al Hibbs and Walford (in
glasses) used Reno roulette winnings to fund a 1949
sailing trip.
|
Left: Walford studied the body
temperatures of Yogis; Above: 1980s aging tests with
middle-aged mice led to his own drastic diet for
longevity. |
National Institutes of Health Institute on
Aging Web site has information on the physiology and
biochemistry of aging: www.nih.gov/health/chip/nia/aging.Find
everything you wanted to know about Walford and more, from his
experiences in the Biosphere to his diet plans to his books:
http://www.walford.com/. The Biosphere 2
homepage offers design plans, research projects, and visitor
information: http://www.bio2.edu/.
Walford’s dream of extending his own life span
became more tangible in the early 1980s, when he and his
then-student Rick Weindruch demonstrated that middle-aged mice
could also benefit from caloric restriction. Up to that point,
says Weindruch, now at the University of Wisconsin Medical
School, experiments by other researchers had involved sudden
caloric restrictions of obese young mice. One day the mice ate
to their hearts’ content; the next day they were on a strict
diet. The results, as often as not, were prematurely dead
mice. Weindruch and Walford took year-old mice and over the
course of two months eased them into a restricted-calorie
diet. The mice lived up to 20 percent longer than their peers.
The work persuaded Walford to severely cut his own caloric
intake. “Roy was toying with the idea before,” says Weindruch.
“This made him serious.”
Walford has kept to his starvation diet for
nearly 20 years. On a typical day, he has a low-fat milkshake,
a banana, some yeast, and some berries for breakfast. Lunch is
a large vegetable salad, and dinner is fish, a baked sweet
potato, and vegetables. His daily calorie count comes to about
half the 3,000 calories per day many Americans eat. Even Hibbs
lacks the wherewithal to try such an extreme diet. “It’s just
very difficult,” he says. “Damn few people, including me, are
willing to put up with it.”
The paradoxical aspect of Walford’s theory of
signposts is that some of them seem preordained to get in the
way of his personal pursuit of longevity. At age 48, for
example, he decided the time had come to attempt a wheelie on
his motorcycle while driving down Santa Monica Boulevard in
Los Angeles. He broke both his motorcycle and his leg when the
former fell on top of the latter. Two years later, he took a
sabbatical from ucla to spend a year walking across India in
“something like a loincloth,” measuring the body temperatures
of Indian holy men he met along the way. “I put a thermometer
up them,” Walford says. “You know, you can do whatever you
want on a sabbatical.” At 59, he decided to trek 2,000 miles
across Africa, from Dar es Salaam to Kinshasa, a
walking/hitchhiking/riverboat tour interrupted by authorities
in upper Zaire (Democratic Republic of the Congo), who accused
him of being a spy.
Walford managed to survive all these
signposts, only to be nearly done in by the one “rather crazy”
thing that had the gestalt of science: Biosphere 2, a huge
sealed greenhouse in the Arizona desert dreamed up by one John
Allen, an engineer, poet, and playwright who got the $150
million to build it from Texas billionaire Ed Bass. Biosphere
2 (Earth is Biosphere 1, say the Biospherians), covering more
than three acres of desert and 10 stories high, was hyped as
the most ambitious closed ecosystem in history. Walford’s
friend Hibbs, recruited for the Biosphere’s project advisory
panel, says Allen and his colleagues were surprised when
Walford agreed to join the crew. “They had trouble believing
that this rather active research physician at ucla was serious
about spending two years locked up in the Biosphere,” he says.
“I told them that I never heard him say anything like this
that he didn’t mean.”
|
LIVING IN A GLASS HOUSE:
Top Left: “We were on
display,” says Walford of his two-year stay in Biosphere
2 in Arizona during the early 1990s; Bottom Left: As
crew doctor, he hooked up Mark van Thillo for an
electrocardiogram; Below: as jack-of-all-trades, he
repaired an atmospheric sensor.
|
In September 1991, at age 67, Walford walked in with his
seven colleagues and the door was closed behind them. The
colleague closest to him in age was 40; the others were an
average of nearly 10 years younger than that.
It is characteristic of Walford that he
describes what happened next as “kind of a miracle,” despite
its lasting effect on his health. “I’d been working on caloric
restriction in animals for 20 years,” he says. “And when we
got inside, we found we couldn’t produce enough food to feed
us all. But what we did produce was very high in quality. So I
took advantage of that and told the people it’s nutritious and
it’s healthy, but you’re going to be hungry. They could elect
that food be sent in from the outside, or they could elect to
live on a healthy starvation diet.” The Biospherians went for
the starvation diet—vegetables and a half-glass of goat’s milk
every day, meat once a week—for two years. Walford might have
survived unimpaired had it not required what he describes as
an “ungodly” amount of work to keep the Biosphere going.
“Eight people running an entire mini-world, unable to call in
an electrician or a plumber or anything, anybody,” he says.
Six days a week, three hours a day, the Biospherians did heavy
manual labor in the fields. Walford was also responsible for
the functioning of 500 atmospheric sensors, many of which hung
from the rafters.
“I was climbing all over the structure,” he says, “and
it was physically exhausting and psychologically stressful.”
His weight dropped to 119 pounds. “I was
really emaciated,” he says. “And the workload kind of
destroyed my back.” A more insidious problem may have come
from nitrous oxide poisoning. Nitrous oxide is a gas released
into the atmosphere by the respiration of microorganisms in
the soil, but it is broken down into its harmless components
by ultraviolet light from the sun. The glass roof of the
Biosphere, however, blocked ultraviolet light, and the nitrous
oxide gradually reached concentrations 100 times that of the
outside world. “Long continuous inhalation is toxic,” says
Walford. “It knocks out the cells in the brain that have to do
with motion.”
Walford’s balance problems apparently started
in the Biosphere; he says he didn’t realize it at the time,
but he can see it now when he looks at himself in old
videotapes. The official diagnosis when he got out was
peripheral and central nervous system damage, and, despite
back and hand surgery, he has never been the same. Once he
starts walking, Walford can keep going in a kind of
slow-motion, joglike gait, but getting himself going is a
challenge.
‘It always seemed there were so
many things to do in life that the first thing to do was live
longer’
“I am in good shape for someone who
is 75,” says Walford, standing in the doorway of his
home office. Fitness machines are the main source for
his cardiovascular exercise. “Using a treadmill is
easier for me than walking because the motion is very
even,” he says. |
Walford’s
apartment, which he shares with Swami, a bluepoint Himalayan
cat, resembles a New York artist’s loft and is cluttered with
memorabilia of his life and travels, much of which seems
devoted to the female body. Hibbs, who recently paid a visit,
says Walford’s concern with living forever may be linked to a
“so many women, so little time” sensibility. Although married
for 20 years and the father of three children, Walford has
been single since 1972. “Now he likes to jump from woman to
woman quite frequently,” says Hibbs, “although they always
seem to be the same women. He keeps rotating among them.”
Walford says there may be some truth to the
so-many-women-so-little-time theory, but he prefers a broader
explanation: He has always had too many projects going at one
time, and women just happen to be a part of them. “It always
seemed there were so many things to do in life that the first
thing to do was live longer,” he says.
Among his projects is a book about the Biosphere that he
expects will take at least five years to complete. He’s also
working on a Biosphere documentary based on 80 hours of
videotape he took while inside. He’s collaborating with Natasa
Prosenc, a Fulbright scholar and a video artist. She’s the
expert documentarian, says Walford, but he’s taking a course
in multimedia and has built a “mini-postproduction studio” in
the room next to his office.
Once those projects are complete, further studies in
history or mathematics may be next. “I like them both,” he
says, “but I don’t know how I’d do as a mathematician.” The
uncertainty seems to entice him. The line on mathematicians is
that they do their best work before they hit 30, after which
it’s a downhill journey. “It would be interesting to try my
hand at mathematics,” he says, “because everybody assumes it’s
a young man’s trip.”
Meanwhile, he’s hoping the genetically engineered mice he’s
raising in a pathogen-free environment will help uncover more
secrets of the aging process. That, of course, harking back to
Biosphere 2, raises the obvious question: Would Walford live
in a hermetically sealed, pathogen-free plastic bubble, if
that’s what it would take to add 20 or 30 more years to his
life?
“Well, I’d do it for a while. Sure. I mean, look around
you,” he says, laughing and pointing to his windowless office,
living room, and video-art studio shut off from the outside
world. “I could live in here for a long time and keep pretty
happy doing all the stuff that I do.”